By Brian Summerfield, Online Editor, REALTOR® Magazine
The NAR Board of Directors voted Saturday to send two recommendations regarding acceptable use of IDX data back to the Multiple Listing Policy Committee because the committee is currently reviewing all IDX policies with an eye toward updating them. The action came at the board meeting that concluded the national association’s 2009 NAR Midyear Legislation Meetings & Trade Expo in Washington, D.C.
IDX, or Internet Data Exchange, refers to a system and process that allows multiple listing service participants to display each others’ property listings on their web sites.
The recommended changes to the IDX rules were as follows (underlined sections indicate proposed additions, strikeouts indicate proposed deletions):
1. Multiple Listing Policy Statement 7.58, paragraph 2, Policies Applicable to Participants’ IDX Sites, Internet Data Exchange (“IDX”) Policy: “Participants must protect IDX information from misappropriation by employing reasonable efforts to monitor and prevent “scraping” or other unauthorized accessing reproduction, or uses. of the MLS database. This requirement does not prohibit indexing of IDX sites by search engines.
2. Section 18.2.2, model MLS rules: “Participants must protect IDX information from misappropriation by employing reasonable efforts to monitor and prevent “scraping” or other unauthorized accessing, reproduction, or uses. of the MLS database. This requirement does not prohibit indexing of IDX sites by search engines.
In discussion of the issue at the board meeting, an NAR director from Indianapolis rose to suggest the recommendations be sent back to MLS committee, since this group is already reviewing all aspects of the IDX policy, first implemented in 2002, with an eye toward updating them. The move to refer back was driven not by any objections to the actual proposals, the speaker said, but rather by the fact that neither the MLS committee nor NAR directors had sufficient time to review the changes and consider their implications.
The IDX rule on scraping — a term that refers to the harvesting of Internet data, often for unauthorized use — was passionately discussed on the Agent Genius real estate blog and others last week after a local board of REALTORS®’ interpretation of the rule that was backed by NAR found that the rule prohibited property listings from being indexed on search engines such as Google. In response to the concerns about this interpretation expressed by hundreds of REALTORS® on the blog, NAR’s MLS Committee took up the issue at its meeting earlier this week.
In that meeting, a majority of the committee agreed that “scraping” and “indexing” are different forms of data use and approved the revisions to the IDX rules that specifically allow the “indexing” of IDX data rule by search engines. Revisions to the rule were prepared just days before the committee meeting, so that the committee could consider them at its upcoming meeting.
The NAR director who spoke to the board expressed concern at the speed at which these changes were about to be implemented, possibly without full consideration of their implications.
The vote of the NAR directors to refer the IDX rule changes back to the committee was closest of the meeting, requiring board members to hold up placards after the typical voice vote proved inconclusive.
What do you think of these proposed changes? Would they significantly impact the way you do business on the Web? Let us know!